cim_MeterReadings_ReadingQualityTypes.ttl issues

[VladimirAlexiev]

<http://data.europa.eu/energy/MeterReadingsQualityTypes>
        rdf:type            skos:ConceptScheme ;
        dcterms:identifier  "6074aa6b-de29-41bc-a4b5-b2bedbeaeffd" ;
        dcterms:modified    "2022-02-18" ;
        skos:definition     "Meter Reading Quality Types"@en ;
        skos:prefLabel      "MeterReadingsQualityTypes" ;
        dcat:version        "1" .

<http://data.europa.eu/energy/MeterReadingsQualityTypes/1.4.131>
        rdf:type                   "cim:ReadingQualityType" ;
        rdf:type                   skos:Concept ;
        cim:IdentifiedObject.description
                "Value Acquired By HHT" ;
        cim:IdentifiedObject.mRID  "f989e6a8-0371-52e1-bd8e-70144a92e936" ;
        cim:IdentifiedObject.name  "1.4.131" ;
        cim:ReadingQualityType.category
                "Data collection related" ;
        cim:ReadingQualityType.subCategory
                "Manual Read" ;
        cim:ReadingQualityType.systemId
                "End Device" ;
        dcterms:identifier         "1.4.131" ;
        skos:definition            "Value Acquired By HHT"@en ;
        skos:inScheme              <http://data.europa.eu/energy/MeterReadingsQualityTypes> ;

• 1: uses different base http://data.europa.eu/energy/
• 2: rename to cim_MeterReadingsQualityTypes.ttl to more closely reflect the contnts
• 3: "2022-02-18" -> "2022-02-18"^^xsd:date
• 4: type "cim:ReadingQualityType" is broken (string not URL)
• 5: prefLabel "MeterReadingsQualityTypes" is no label, which should be an English phrase not CamelCasedPhrase
• 6: definition "Meter Reading Quality Types"@en is no definition: that's the prefLabel
• 7: put the GUID in dct:identifier as in BaseVoltage.ttl.
• 8: put "1.4.131" in skos:notation and remove it from name
• 9: put "Value Acquired By HHT"@en in skos:prefLabel
• 10: dcat:version might be a bit problematic:
  • It's only introduced in DCAT3 but there's no RDF definition for it: https://www.w3.org/ns/dcat is DCAT2: provide DCAT3 RDF and ttl downloads w3c/dxwg#1533
  • It's unclear whether it can be applied to ConceptScheme because https://w3c.github.io/dxwg/dcat/#Property:resource_version doesn't define a domain, and https://w3c.github.io/dxwg/dcat/#version-info only gives an example with dcat:Dataset: can dcat:version be used on any resource? w3c/dxwg#1534
  • But I'm tolerant towards reusing props in a wider context, so I think such use is ok
• 11: category, subCategory suggest that you should make another ConceptScheme, turn these values to Concepts and add broader relation between them
• 12: Similarly, systemId could be turned into a resource. At least, you can later attach multilingual labels to it; and it might be possible there is extra data about these system types?
• 13: systemId is not a precise name, systemType would be better. But I guess you generate all this automatically from CIM, so no manual tweaking is "allowed"

[Haigutus]

on hold for now, the example is in poor state at the moment, to continue working, waiting input - #3