Thanks for destroying art

[Naugustogi]

Are we now going to fuck artists over even more?

If anything no piece of art can be trusted of not being ai generated anymore. And if you try to prove you've made it, well nope. This now allows to fake anything. Nobody will trust you anymore. This is fucked up beyond recognition.

You killed art, forever, you dont understand the craft, yet you try to mimick it.

I wish for justice. May your own creation destroy you.

[BlackHoleNo-23]

well, don't make it feel more proud

[tonyshen36]

shit artists are so pissed they can't sell shit art anymore lmao

[Naugustogi]

shit artists are so pissed they can't sell shit art anymore lmao

You dont understand the problem. This society is build on trust. If you give your girlfriend an hardworked artpiece, or she gives you one, well good luck having trust issues.

If you cant express your thoughts anymore, then ai can overtake that too, individuality will be banned.

At that point i dont want to delete any new technology, i want to delete the people working on it, not having any morality or thoughts over what they destroy. Not writing the ethical possibilitys, just putting something out without much writing how it works.

Like the atomic Bomb, not knowing what it can destroy, just putting it out without much thoughts. Considering that it could've ignites the atmosphere.

Now the real evil lies in building it in the first place.

[barepixels]

JapanYoshi

Let see your work and we will tell you if it's good or bad. You talk as if you are some sort of "art god" without showing us anything

What the fuck is "actual art" anyway? Who made you the authority for art

[barepixels]

I was replying to JapanYoshi

see the paragraph before my reply

calling people "shit artists" but have nothing to show

[Naugustogi]

I was replying to JapanYoshi

see the paragraph before my reply

I apologise, my mistake.

[barepixels]

What if one like one of the key frame better than the final image? Should we let JapanYoshi rob us from such opportunity / tool?

[ruby109]

wow, so you can define art?

[protector131090]

Are we now going to fuck artists over even more?

If anything no piece of art can be trusted of not being ai generated anymore. And if you try to prove you've made it, well nope. This now allows to fake anything. Nobody will trust you anymore. This is fucked up beyond recognition.

You killed art, forever, you dont understand the craft, yet you try to mimick it.

I wish for justice. May your own creation destroy you.

are you from Middle Ages? Photography destroyed art 50+ years ago. THan photoshop complitely destroyed art. art was dead for a long time.

[Naugustogi]

Are we now going to fuck artists over even more?
If anything no piece of art can be trusted of not being ai generated anymore. And if you try to prove you've made it, well nope. This now allows to fake anything. Nobody will trust you anymore. This is fucked up beyond recognition.
You killed art, forever, you dont understand the craft, yet you try to mimick it.
I wish for justice. May your own creation destroy you.

are you from Middle Ages? Photography destroyed art 50+ years ago. THan photoshop complitely destroyed art. art was dead for a long time.

Ah there are no people left holding a pen and draw on paper? Computers are a different technology. I guess i have to use a stone and draw something on another stone. Wait thats a tool, so i have finger nails, i can simply scratch something into the ground, now happy?

[protector131090]

Are we now going to fuck artists over even more?
If anything no piece of art can be trusted of not being ai generated anymore. And if you try to prove you've made it, well nope. This now allows to fake anything. Nobody will trust you anymore. This is fucked up beyond recognition.
You killed art, forever, you dont understand the craft, yet you try to mimick it.
I wish for justice. May your own creation destroy you.

are you from Middle Ages? Photography destroyed art 50+ years ago. THan photoshop complitely destroyed art. art was dead for a long time.

Ah there are no people left holding a pen and draw on paper? Computers are a different technology. I guess i have to use a stone and draw something on another stone. Wait thats a tool, so i have finger nails, i can simply scratch something into the ground, now happy?

You just proved my point. There always will be people who want to draw no mater what tech we have. Ai is not exeption. Ai will never be a threat to real artist. Only to mediocre designers. With ai boom real art peaces will skydive in cost. Real artist will be celebrated like never before course they will be extremely rare.

[noorus]

What if one like one of the key frame better than the final image? Should we let JapanYoshi rob us from such opportunity / tool?

If you drew the final image, surely you could go back to one of the "key frames" regardless?

[trentmkelly]

@Naugustogi
You have LLM projects posted on Github. Why is it destroying art, fucking over artists, the end of the world when it's image generation AI, but not destroying literature, fucking over writers, the end of the world when it's text generation AI?

[shenleqinau]

我们现在要把艺术家搞得更多吗？

如果有的话，没有任何艺术品可以相信不再是人工智能生成的。如果你试图证明你已经成功了，那么不。这现在允许伪造任何东西。没有人会再信任你了。这简直面目全非。

你扼杀了艺术，永远，你不了解这门手艺，但你试图模仿它。

我希望伸张正义。愿你自己的创造摧毁你。

我们现在要把艺术家搞得更多吗？

如果有的话，没有任何艺术品可以相信不再是人工智能生成的。如果你试图证明你已经成功了，那么不。这现在允许伪造任何东西。没有人会再信任你了。这简直面目全非。

你扼杀了艺术，永远，你不了解这门手艺，但你试图模仿它。

我希望伸张正义。愿你自己的创造摧毁你。

“It’s hilarious, if you can’t compete with skill, you’re destroying art. Anyway, you ‘artists’ are always right. If you’re not good, practice more. If you can’t handle losing, don’t play. It raises the overall watchability of creations, and it doesn’t affect artists with high painting skills at all.”

[PPAngel345]

我们现在要把艺术家搞得更多吗？

如果有的话，没有任何艺术品可以相信不再是人工智能生成的。如果你试图证明你已经成功了，那么不。这现在允许伪造任何东西。没有人会再信任你了。这简直面目全非。

你扼杀了艺术，永远，你不了解这门手艺，但你试图模仿它。

我希望伸张正义。愿你自己的创造摧毁你。

我们现在要把艺术家搞得更多吗？

如果有的话，没有任何艺术品可以相信不再是人工智能生成的。如果你试图证明你已经成功了，那么不。这现在允许伪造任何东西。没有人会再信任你了。这简直面目全非。

你扼杀了艺术，永远，你不了解这门手艺，但你试图模仿它。

我希望伸张正义。愿你自己的创造摧毁你。

“It’s hilarious, if you can’t compete with skill, you’re destroying art. Anyway, you ‘artists’ are always right. If you’re not good, practice more. If you can’t handle losing, don’t play. It raises the overall watchability of creations, and it doesn’t affect artists with high painting skills at all.”

Art is something you, for instance, enjoy. Not watch, nobody says watch art, if you can't even handle basic English, how can you write a prompt? I might even be a better AI bro than you, so why even spending time following the damn project? It's useless.

[Seedmanc]

Artists started this war, no complains on losing it now. We just wanted to have fun with the new tech making us cute waifus, but they came in with hatred.

[barepixels]

What if one like one of the key frame better than the final image? Should we let JapanYoshi rob us from such opportunity / tool?

If you drew the final image, surely you could go back to one of the "key frames" regardless?

I don't think you will remember every step, hence the benefit of having history to refresh your memory and allowing you to do A B comparison

One of the key frame will not be exactly the same as one of your step since it is synthetic but you might like it better.

[noorus]

What if one like one of the key frame better than the final image? Should we let JapanYoshi rob us from such opportunity / tool?

If you drew the final image, surely you could go back to one of the "key frames" regardless?

I don't think you will remember every step, hence the benefit of having history to refresh your memory and allowing you to do A B comparison

One of the key frame will not be exactly the same as one of your step since it is synthetic but you might like it better.

It is literally not history when it is synthesized nonsense, and this is not a function anyone needs for a legitimate purpose. This project's purpose is to fake process videos so that stolen and/or generated pictures can be sold as legitimate.

[Elvira626]

Naugustogi, don't worry. They can't fool everyone all the time. They can't destroy anything.

Genuine, skilled artists need to get back to the basics with pencil, paper, canvas, and paint. AI cannot fake that, and these tech bros who refuse to learn how to paint and draw cannot compete with someone who actually can paint. We have authenticity; they don't.

Pull the plug on electricity and they've got nothing. Their "creativity" is null. But even a digital-only artist can quickly adapt to traditional media. We have the real knowledge and skills. We can adapt. Furthermore, we don't "need" some stupid thing like this to scam and fool other people into thinking we actually drew something ourselves.

They've gotten so audacious I just don't care anymore. They're absurd. We'll have to up our game, but ultimately, there's a limit to how much they can fake. They can't fake it ALL and they know it.

[xiaoleexiang]

Naugustogi, don't worry. They can't fool everyone all the time. They can't destroy anything.

Genuine, skilled artists need to get back to the basics with pencil, paper, canvas, and paint. AI cannot fake that, and these tech bros who refuse to learn how to paint and draw cannot compete with someone who actually can paint. We have authenticity; they don't.

Pull the plug on electricity and they've got nothing. Their "creativity" is null. But even a digital-only artist can quickly adapt to traditional media. We have the real knowledge and skills. We can adapt. Furthermore, we don't "need" some stupid thing like this to scam and fool other people into thinking we actually drew something ourselves.

They've gotten so audacious I just don't care anymore. They're absurd. We'll have to up our game, but ultimately, there's a limit to how much they can fake. They can't fake it ALL and they know it.

This is last year, buddy:

• https://interestingengineering.com/innovation/ai-powered-robot-can-reproduce-artists-paintings-at-scale
• https://www.acrylicrobotics.ca/

[Elvira626]

This is last year, buddy:

* https://interestingengineering.com/innovation/ai-powered-robot-can-reproduce-artists-paintings-at-scale

* https://www.acrylicrobotics.ca/

Are you serious? You seriously think that the computer/robot using one brush to "paint by numbers" is comparable to this? https://www.youtube.com/live/hL78FITGYdA?si=6QCzEl0XCaQ8522S or this? https://youtu.be/3K5FvNRCLkM?si=ATEwuvh2g7Hr9VAe https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zD-cW8Ov9f8

Traditional media, especially oils, require a more subtle touch, many different brushes, many different brush strokes, brushwork and handling. Scrumbling, glazing, dry brush, palette knife, impasto, wipeaway, toning, wash, smearing, blending, yadda yadda. This stupid computer with one brush "filling in the blanks" line by line isn't even in the same stratosphere.

And besides that, I was talking about AI faking "work in progress" videos. You know, faking a video of a human being in front of a canvas, painting, mixing paints, etc. When do you propose that AI will be able to convincingly create a video of a person (who must look identical to the would-be scammer) "painting" in front of an easel, mixing paints, talking about their color mixtures, commenting on the adjustments they're making, real time? That's what these videos I linked to are showing. That's what genuine artists are capable of doing and are doing now. Can AI replicate this completely convincingly?

[xiaoleexiang]

@Elvira626 Oh, no! That's SO TRUE! They'll really never be able to reproduce the sweat on your forehead, or the stink emanating from your body, right? That's really impossible, for sure. They will never be able to do that. Wow. I guess you won then, right? It doesn't matter that the bot from a year ago could masterfully paint a masterpiece on a canvas if it can't... if it can't do something that is completely needless? LMAO

[Elvira626]

@Elvira626 Oh, no! That's SO TRUE! They'll really never be able to reproduce the sweat on your forehead, or the stink emanating from your body, right? That's really impossible, for sure. They will never be able to do that. Wow. I guess you won then, right? It doesn't matter that the bot from a year ago could masterfully paint a masterpiece on a canvas if it can't... if it can't do something that is completely needless? LMAO

LOL, you are just butthurt because you proved yourself to be completely clueless and ignorant about what traditional art entails. You seriously thought that showing me this robot doing some basic "paint by numbers" was some sort of "gotcha"? Like, "oops, wow, they're already able to replace traditional artists!" lol! You seriously thought that this painting robot's work is comparable to the majority of traditional art, and in particular traditional art painted in the style that tech bros most love to "emulate"?

We're here talking about AI being able to fake WIPs and when I bring up that AI can't fake traditional art, you bring in your stupid paint-by-number robot? Ooooh, you got me with that one, lol.

[lllyasviel]

Hi all, as an action of GitHub ToS we must lock this thread.

For future comments please follow the instructions here.